NA Panel Concerned Over PTCL’s Failure to Provide List of Properties

Staff Report:

The National Assembly Standing Committee on Information Technology (IT) on Thursday expressed displeasure over PTCL’s failure to provide the list of properties despite clear directions from the Committee.

Consequently, the NA body has directed that the complete property list be presented in the next meeting.PTCL Group Launches Pakistan’s First 800G Wavelength Division

PTCL, referring to a clause in the Sales and Purchase Agreement, stated that it retains the right to buy and sell properties.

However, it was noted that since 2007, no practical action has been taken beyond the agreement itself. The Committee was informed that the Privatization Commission serves as the custodian of the Sales and Purchase Agreement of PTCL and oversees all related matters.

Additionally, it was clarified that PTCL cannot sell any property without prior approval from its board.

Etisalat has yet to make 33% of its payments, despite the government transferring property titles to it. The Minister briefed the Committee that a Special Committee, led by the Finance Minister and including all stakeholders, has been formed to address this issue.

The Committee directed that the findings of this Special Committee be presented in the next meeting for review and resolution.

Additionally, it was instructed that the Sales and Purchase Agreement of PTCL with ETISALAT be shared to examine its clauses in detail.

The Committee further instructed that the Minister and Secretary of Law & Justice be invited in the next meeting to present their perspectives. The committee emphasized that their input is crucial for a comprehensive review of the issue and to ensure an effective resolution.

The NA body deferred the discussion on the Digital Nation Pakistan Bill and deliberations will be held in the next meeting, with input from PPP members and other parties.

Opposition Leader Omar Ayub criticized the frequent internet shutdowns, allegedly orchestrated by intelligence agencies. He highlighted the substantial economic losses, amounting to millions of dollars, and lamented Pakistan’s low internet speeds.

He stated that improvements promised by October 31st have yet to materialize. He also raised concerns about the misuse of VPNs, which he claimed are being used against the people.

Committee member Romina Khurshid Alam defended the need for monitoring activities, citing global practices. “If something poses a threat to the state, it must be monitored,” she said, adding that even cartoons are monitored in foreign countries. She reaffirmed the committee’s role in strengthening the nation.

Minister of State Shaza Fatima Khawaja pointed to increasing terrorism incidents and internal security challenges. She questioned the rationale behind internet shutdowns, stating that Pakistan exported $1.5 billion last month despite connectivity issues.

She assured the committee that the problems have been resolved and revealed ongoing talks with Starlink to bring satellite internet to Pakistan.

PPP leader Sharmila Farooqi criticized the lack of progress after four meetings, citing significant losses suffered by businesses like her husband’s e-commerce company.

“Every time PTI calls for a protest, the internet is shut down. Are we fools to keep attending these meetings when no solutions are provided?” she questioned.

Syed Aminul Haq emphasized the importance of uninterrupted, high-speed internet to boost IT exports to $15 billion. “We must ensure the internet is always fast and reliable,” he said.

The NA body stated that PTA had previously informed the Committee that the internet situation in the country would improve by October, 2024.

However, concerns persist regarding ongoing internet issues, which are causing the country financial losses amounting to millions of dollars.

The Chairman PTA took oath and said that three out of seven submarine cables had been damaged, leading to significant internet disruptions in the country.

He further explained that internet shutdowns are enforced by PTA based on directions from the Federal Government, the Ministry of Interior, and Courts during law and order situations. The Chairman assured the committee that PTA has no malicious intentions and that all actions are taken to address the country’s prevailing circumstances responsibly.

“If I am acting unlawfully, I will resign immediately,” he asserted.

 The Chairman added that the current allocation of 270 MHz spectrum is insufficient for the country’s population of 240 million, resulting in network choking issues.

However, he announced that a 5G spectrum auction is planned for April, which will significantly improve the internet situation in the country. The PTA Chairman highlighted that over the past six years, PTA has contributed PKR 1700 billion to the exchequer from the telecom sector.

However, he expressed disappointment over the lack of government investment in infrastructure improvement and development.

He also informed the committee that four new submarine cables are being introduced, which will further enhance the country’s internet performance. These developments are expected to address current connectivity challenges and support the growth of the digital economy.